Why Should a Great Mind Map Matter to You as an Author?
I’m going to share with you a tool and a methodology, both of which have already paid me handsome dividends for my current long-form writing project, a novel, and for all my future novels… for less than twenty bucks.
The tool is called Scapple, NOT Scalpel! Polar opposites… read on, intrepid scribe…
So what the heck is Scapple?
Well, it’s not only a mind mapping tool, it’s a piece of companion software to the amazing writer’s program called Scrivener. Both programs are offered by a British company with the coolest name ever: Literature & Latte. Even though I swore off caffeine last year, I still love the name, and I can still smell a seductive aroma.
Click here for my earlier review of Scrivener, but that is largely irrelevant to this article. Read on!
First, why is a mind map important to an author, especially for long-form projects like a novel?
Recently, several of my readers have suggested that I locate my customary cast of characters page at the beginning of my books. Since I cast a lot of characters in my stories, most of near-epic length, this is either a simple helpful suggestion or an indictment of too many characters. I’m hoping its the former, not the latter. Either way, it’s a good idea shared by some famous best sellers.
That got me thinking if I couldn’t do better beyond just moving my character list and a brief sentence of their role in the book. Enter the mind map and tools to ease the task of creating one. I’ve used mind maps for a few years now in writing the book. Now I’m considering incorporating them in my published works.
So let’s define the word Scapple, the name of a tool I’m growing to really love:
- To work roughly, or shape without finishing
- To dress in any way short of fine tooling or rubbing, as stone.
Yup, I start documenting my early writing workflow for my latest book with a tool called Scapple–to rough out a story, to imagine and to define character and multiple story line relationships. Helps alleviate an otherwise encroaching cloud of insanity. We’ll examine my current work in progress to illustrate.
I’m in the early stages of creating the final book in a near-future dystopian science fiction trilogy. And yes, I’m writing the middle book last. I’ve entitled it Amidst the Mayhem. Most of my books weave lots of characters in and around at least a few different story lines. This type of project is not for the feint of heart, but gives a story depth and dimension.
In the past I’ve pressed various mind mapping tools into service, some free, but none really met my needs. Most are hierarchical, like branches on a tree, or progressive forks in a road. Scapple is better for diagramming any-to-any relationships, which is precisely what I needed.
See the resource list at the end of this article for other similar tools. You can peruse over a hundred possible mind mapping tools and techniques from that list. I also offer you “how to” references.
Scapple is fast, simple, effective, and works well with my favorite writing software, Scrivener.
Check out my own big picture diagram below for my latest novel. Scapple neatly pulled together, in one info-packed diagram, my brainstorming of a list of characters and their relationships to each other. I consolidated phrases jotted down on single sheets of paper, scribbles from various Post-It Notes™, various pages of sundry notebooks, and transcriptions of 2AM whispered voice recordings–you know, like most authors do.
This data collection took about a half-dozen hours spanning several days. I then spent just two hours to shop for the right mind-mapping software, another ten minutes to buy, download and install Scapple, plus maybe another hour to learn the program. Easy.
Heck, I spent more time than that tweaking a perfectly good diagram, just because it was fun!
This intuitive diagram now captures the entire extensive cast of characters of my new novel and their relationships within three different story lines in one powerful visual. You’ll note this is version 4. It is so fast and easy to update and export or print, I am really impressed:
Here is why this diagram is so powerful:
- Every node in the diagram is called a note. Notes may be easily connected to other notes to signify a relationship just by dragging one on top of the other. These connections can be labeled to further identify their relationship. Huh? Keep reading…
- In this example, each of the three largest rectangles comprise a unique but relevant story line in this novel (labeled Story Line A, Story Line B, & Story Line C). And I’ve characterized each with a representative label (Triple Linchpin, Pro-Corp, & Pro-Gov’t, as well as their settings’ geographical locations)
- Within each story line box you’ll see primary characters enclosed in colored boxes, secondaries in a larger boldface font, & tertiaries in regular (non-bold) smaller font. These are my own arbitrary conventions (I started from a blank page and just went crazy!)
- You can see the arrows connecting the notes suggest their relationships–in this case, between characters I plan to include in this novel. I use these labels on these arrows to further define unique relationships between specific characters
- You also can see a few connections (arrows, aka relationships) connecting characters across the big rectangles. This illustrates that some primary and secondary characters span more than one story line, and some don’t, but none span all three story lines. This helps me plan how these stories intersect within the book to develop a solid throughline (a theme that runs through the entire book).
- That is a lot of information conveyed in a one-page diagram, isn’t it? Thi is my ‘god’s eye view,’ which keeps me focused as I now fill in the gaps throughout the writing process within Scrivener.
- While functionally simple, Scapple features powerful features for:
- Simplicity:
- To create a new note, just double click anywhere on the board and start typing
- All commands are accessed from the tool bar OR via straightforward keyboard shortcuts (I keep a short cheat sheet–a Post-It Note™–stuck to the bottom of my monitor for handy reference)
- Formatting and arranging:
- When typing a lot of text into a note (see another example below), formatting the shape of the note is as simple as dragging a corner or edge to expand or contract its horizontal and/or vertical dimensions
- To connect two notes, just drag and drop one note onto another, and they revert to their original locations, but now they’re connected
- To change the connection from a dotted line to a directional or bi-directional arrow, just also use the command, control, or option keys while dragging (I printed out Scapple’s 2-page Quick Start Guide and I keep that handy. Easy)
- Can do lots more with color, note backgrounds/shapes, etc. But not a lot of foo-foo crap I don’t need (that would slow me and this lightning fast tool down)
- One of the coolest features: when you move a note around (drag ‘n drop), the connectors automagically extend or contract and change angle as necessary. The connection labels follow the lines too
- Aligning connected or unconnected notes horizontally or vertically is a simple select a menu option from the tool bar and click.
- And justifying text inside a note (left, right, or centered) is just as easy
- Lots more too like stacking, background shapes, zooming and navigating, and movement mode.
- Interacting with Scrivener:
- Easy drag ‘n drop or cut ‘n paste multiple elements (notes) from Scapple into the Scrivener binder (file list), and the program automatically creates a document (e.g., scene) within a Scrivener project (aka book) for each note from the Scapple diagram.
- Exporting:
- As a file (PDF)
- Or as an image (PNG)
- Other mind mapping programs offer more export options, but this is all I needed and wanted.
- Simplicity:
So the next logical progression? Why not include a completed mind map at the beginning of each of my novels with a robust cast? George RR Martin includes maps of the Seven Kingdoms in his books, as does JRR Tokein with a map of Middle Earth. Why not a relationship map of my Mayhem characters? They can’t stop me!
Bonus Tip:
I’m also finding this tool incredibly helpful for mapping concepts I’m learning as I structure this latest work in progress. Mind mapping is also a wonderful technique for visualizing an overall project, for getting my mental arms wrapped around a 70- to 100-thousand word story beyond basic story structure and character relationships. Applying Scapple to that task is equally useful and productive, at least for my mental workflow.
For example, I just read (twice) a new (to me) Kindle book called Write Your Novel From the Middle by James Scott Bell. This is a wonderful little book that I found immensely instructional.
Bell presents a method for nailing the structure and continuity or theme (a book’s throughline) of a long-form writing project like a novel by first identifying what he refers to as a mirror moment (MM). Within a scene during a moment of introspection, a character asks several important questions of herself, perhaps looking at a mirror. This moment–near the midpoint of a story–is a pivotal point that defines what the story is really all about. That is where we start.
Then, and only then, according to Bell, should we return to an earlier point in the outline (or scene list) and define that character’s pre-story psychology (PSP). Or we may choose to jump ahead to the end of the story and sketch out or write that story’s or character’s transformation (T). But the mirror moment is what generates the project’s heat, as Bell says, the continuity between the early story and its ending.
Bell calls these three points his Golden Triangle. Some author’s refer to that as the character’s arc. Bell simply suggests an elegant and simplified point of view for implementing that important concept, expanding it to integrate the story’s theme.
I’ve embedded all of these diagrams for easy reference in the Scrivener project for Mayhem: Underground… As I add scenes, I’ll refer to these diagrams to stay on track. I can even view each diagram alongside the scene I’m currently crafting.
So how cool is that? Now I’m brainstorming scenes that connect the dots. Or in this case, the scenes that connect the three corners of Bell’s Golden Triangle: three major scene signposts for each of the three main characters in each of the three story lines to ensure the story flows with punch and continuity:
- The mirror moment (either character-driven or plot-driven) placed well within Act 2 of a three-act structure for each story line (circa the book’s midpoint),
- The pre-story psychology (background early in the book) for the major characters in each story line that makes the mirror moment necessary, and
- The transformation experienced by each of those characters at the end of the book which brings the reader to confident closure.
I combined this Golden Triangle methodology with Bell’s Fourteen Signpost Scenes, another pro-tip in Write From the Middle…
By pasting those scene titles and descriptions into Scrivener’s binder (list of scenes/chapters), the dots are now filling in faster in my mind than I can write them!
For me (your mileage may vary), this yields just enough structure to the overall project to ensure a powerful throughline, and it’s fun! At least, that’s Bell’s promise, and… so far, so good.
Of course, I still modify a lot of this stuff as the story evolves, but it’s a great way to hit the keyboard with momentum, and a great way to visualize complex character and story relationships.
Mind-mapping tool selection considerations:
- Most free tools are web-based (an Internet connection is needed for access and use)
- If you’re asked to pay for a tool, look for one with a generous free trial with the tool’s full function (like Scapple) to ensure it’s right for you before plunking down hard-earned cash
- Some of the paid tools might be subscription-based (a monthly fee) or a one-time licensing fee (like Scapple) which is available for either MacOS (like mine) or Windows ($18 USD each). Sadly not available on iOS or Android.
- Look for a tool that fits your particular needs.
- There is a lot of feature overlap between tools, but if you’re going to use such a tool quite a bit (you’ll find reasons!), take a little time to choose your best fit.
Basic selection criteria for a mind mapping tool include:
- Top priority: choose a tool that inspires you to complete your task!
- Free or fee (free isn’t always the best choice, but a free trial usually is)
- Web- or desktop-based
- Hierarchical (most tools) or any-to-any (like Scapple) connections
- Integration with other software you use (e.g., MS Word, Scrivener, other mind mapping tools your friends or collaborators may use)
- Export, save, print, share capabilities (pick the program that allows the output formats you need)
- Full-screen with easy zoom mode. Useful for large complex diagrams
- Sophisticated graphics (images, clip-art, colorful connectors, timeline, 3D view…)
- Input capabilities like weblinks, videos, emoji reactions, and/or music. I chose simple and fast with Scapple as I wasn’t out to create a work of art or a multimedia presentation
- Mind mapping templates if you need something to start from. Some programs provide a library of templates which is useful if you don’t know where to begin, or you have a very task-specific project in mind
- Some tools are very task-specific (e.g., project management, budgeting, teaching, scheduling, Gantt charting, Venn diagrams, checklists, blue prints, spreadsheet-based, team collaboration…)
- Some online tools (won’t work without an Internet connection) require you to create an account to use them. Most are free to create, but may charge you for tool usage once you’re in
- Some provide robust font support
- Some provide a built-in presentation mode
Note: one feature of Scapple could be construed as a disadvantage. While it offers an intuitively simple interface, connectors between nodes are straight lines only, unlike some other tools. That works fine for me, but some might find this limiting.
Mind-mapping resources (some overlap):
- What is Mind Mapping?
- How to Mind Map & 7 Free Open Source Tools
- 99 Mind Mapping Resources, Tools, and Tips
- 11 Free Mind Mapping Applications & Web Services
- 19 BEST Mind Mapping Software in 2020 (Free & Paid)
- Free Mind Mapping on Canva
- The 5 Best Free Mind Mapping Tools for Teachers
- 6 Best Mind Mapping Tools For Creative Students
- Mind Mapping for Kids (video of mind mapping guru, Tony Buzan)
Go crazy!
With pen in hand…
Gene (also at GKJurrens.com)